Skip to content
← Journal

What AI Actually Changed About Making a Commercial

April 18, 2025 · 4 min read

Three parts of the commercial pipeline genuinely collapsed. The rest moved. Moving is not disappearing, and most accounts of AI video production quietly confuse the two.

Run the list as it actually exists on a job: brief, treatment, boards, look development, location, casting, shoot, assembly, grade, versioning, delivery. Eleven steps, depending on how you count the arguments in between. The compression is not spread evenly across them. Three lost their place on the calendar altogether. Several got heavier. One did not shift by a day.

The short version is this. Generative intelligence collapsed the cost of the option. It did nothing to the cost of the decision.

What genuinely collapsed

Three, precisely. Not the whole front half of the process, whatever the decks imply.

Look development. It used to be a board, a reference film, and a fortnight of argument conducted in the abstract. Doré is the clearest case we have: a fluted, scalloped half-disc that returns as a ring, a stud and a hoop, in brushed gold, gunmetal and a pink-violet metal. Pleated metal goes cold on white. You can predict that in a meeting; you cannot settle it in one. The still-life ended up grounded on a backlit banana leaf, a river stone, an open lily, raked sand and driftwood. Reaching those in the old pipeline meant sourcing, a stylist and a test day. Now they exist as frames before anyone has to commit to one.

Location and set. Ramón Béjar's library runs on a single rule: No Faces, Only Storytelling. Nobody appears on screen, so architecture has to carry the film. Building architecture that specific used to mean finding it or constructing it, and both are slow, expensive and geographically stubborn. That step now happens in direction rather than logistics.

Versioning. L'Orientale Fragrances needs the same bottle twice — dark and cinematic, gold and amber on matte glass, shadow doing most of the work, then flat on white for the product grid. That was two setups and two calendar entries. It is now one brief with two outputs, and the art direction survives the jump, which is the entire reason for doing it that way.

What only moved

Continuity moved from the floor to the edit. On a shoot, continuity is somebody's job — a person who notices the cap is rotated the wrong way in take four. Remove the floor and you remove that person. The check does not disappear. It relocates to the assembly, where it is slower and less forgiving, because by then the error is already in the file rather than standing in front of you.

Casting moved into reference discipline. Nothing is cast in the old sense, and every decision about what is allowed in frame still gets made. It gets made earlier, in writing, and it binds harder.

Approvals moved to the front. A client now sees the film — not a treatment, not a board, the film — while it is still cheap to change. That is a real improvement, and it is also why the treatment stage got heavier. The argument has to happen somewhere. Better before the grade than after it.

The step that got harder

Creative direction. Which is not a flattering thing to say about your own discipline, but it is what happened.

The engine will answer any question you put to it, including the wrong one, and it will answer it beautifully. When an option costs nothing, the number of options stops being a constraint — and constraints were doing more work in the old process than anyone admitted. A shoot day forced a decision. A budget forced a decision. Take those away and nothing decides except taste.

The failure mode is visible from across a room. Every frame lands and the piece means nothing. No model upgrade repairs that, because nothing in the model caused it.

So the brief carries weight it never used to carry. Christian Provenzano's house is built on the perfumer rather than the product, which is why the long-form work is composed against classical architecture and the packshots stay clean and slightly withheld. No engine produces that sentence. It only executes it.

What this does to a schedule

The calendar is shorter and lumpier. Weeks of scouting and building come off the front. Shoot days mostly vanish. What remains is a long, unglamorous finishing pass — colour, light, detail, frame by frame — and that pass is exactly as long as it always was.

Anyone quoting you a schedule where the finish shrank too is quoting you a worse film.